As a filmmaker, you know that every week I'm tuned in to watch Fox TV's latest reality gameshow, "On The Lot." This "American Idol" for aspiring filmmakers is executive produced by Steven Spielberg and Mark Burnett (Burnett is creator of "Survivor" and "The Apprentice.") When I first saw commercials for the show, I thought, "Heck, didn't Matt and Ben already do this show on HBO?" However, this show is actually quite different than PGL. I must say that I liked PGL more. That show was focused on the magic of movie making as well as the behind the scenes drama. The Lot really is just a weekly film festival judged by Carrie "Princess Leia" Fisher, Gary "Brother to Penny" Marshall (aka Laverne DeFazio and one of the most successful woman directors in Hollywood) and a guest judge every week.
This week's guest judge was Micheal "Blow 'em up" Bay, who brought you such cinematic masterpieces as "The Rock" and this summers' "Transformers." I have to give Mike much credit. He was no holds barred in his critiques of the contestants' films. He told one contestant that her film was what they call in Hollywood, "A Groaner." (Ouch!). Carrie plays the "Paula Abdul" role nicely, very light on the criticism and squeamish about saying anything too mean. Gary is sort of comic relif. He always has a good joke to throw in, the humor amplified by his Bronx accent.
The contest is now down to 15 filmmakers from all over the country and each week five of them will have their 3 minute films viewed then voted on by the 15 or so people who watch the show (okay, maybe there are more than 15. :-). That's where I come in. Each week (time permitting) I'll give you MY favorite and why. For this week, I actually have two picks.
First, hands down, no contest, the best shot and most professional of this week's five films was Shalini Kantayya's "Laughing Out Loud: A Comic Journey." It's a short documentary about a gay Indian comic. The cinematography and editing were top notch. The others look like amateur films compared to this one. However, the one that held the most entertainment value for me (and by far the most original) was Adam Stein's "Dough: The Musical." The songs were clever and funny, the acting great, and amazingly, it flowed like a true musical. I felt the production quality on this one was also very high.
As much as I enjoy watching the show, it's only because I'm a filmmaker myself and I get a kick out of seeing other people's work. However, I doubt if the show will be back for a second season. The host is not that great and there just isn't enough drama. I want to see more of what happens on set. What made PGL so much fun (particularly season 1) was watching Chris Moore yelling at everybody, and the inter-crew politics and soap opera-like melodrama. There's none of that here. There was in the first episode or two. But now that we're in "film fest" mode, it's gone. They gotta bring that back if they hope to see this baby really take off. IMHO.
technorati tags: On_the_Lot, Steven_Spielber, Mark_Burnett, Shalini_Kantayya, Adam_Stein, Project_Greenlight, Matt_Damon, Ben_Afleck, Carrie_Fisher, Garry_Marshall, Michael_Bay, Chris_Moore, Fox, HBO, Film_Festival, filmmaker